Plenty of Brighton independents have collected a few hundred email addresses at the till over the past year and never emailed any of them. The addresses then sit in a spreadsheet on the shop laptop. The people behind them hear nothing from the shop until they happen to walk past the window again.
Before the first email goes out, that list needs a home that handles the sign-up form, the unsubscribe link and the sending itself. Two widely used tools price their plans by the number of contacts on the list, so the monthly bill rises with the size of the list. A klaviyo vs mailchimp comparison notes that both free plans stop at 250 contacts, so a list of a few hundred addresses already needs a paid plan on either tool. Have your contact count ready when you read it, as each price covers a range of list sizes.
Regulars who already come in every week
Your daily flat white drinker doesn’t yet know that the new single origin beans arrived on Tuesday, or that the bread shelf now carries a rye loaf on Fridays. Keep it short for regulars: what’s new on the counter, a photo and a price.
More shoppers pick email than any other channel for this kind of news. In the DMA’s Consumer Email Tracker 2023, a UK survey of more than 2,000 consumers, 53% ranked email first among marketing channels for hearing about new products and services, and 64% put it first for discounts, offers and sales.
A shop owner who takes a delivery every week has enough for an email every fortnight, and a cafe that changes its menu with the seasons has enough for one a month. Send when your shelf or menu has actually changed. Put the date of the delivery or the new dish in the subject line, so a regular scanning the inbox on the bus sees at once what is new.

What about the customers who only come in a few times a year?
A counter list in Brighton holds plenty of people who come in a few times a year: a day visitor, a student who has since moved away, someone who bought a present and liked the wrapping. They won’t make the trip for a box of new stock. An evening event, a late opening in December or a sale on the last weekend of the season gives them a date to plan around, and for someone who lives two hours away, the website link in that email is the only way to act on it between visits.
Once a month suits this group, with the link to your online shop or booking page near the top of each email.
Consent needs more care with this group, because some of them signed up without buying anything. Under the UK’s electronic marketing rules, a shop that took an address during a sale can email that customer about its own similar products without separate consent, provided the customer was told at the till that marketing would follow and given the chance to opt out there, with an unsubscribe link in every message afterwards. The University of Edinburgh’s guidance on direct marketing sets out those conditions alongside the general rule that other individuals must have opted in. Someone who signed the clipboard at an event without buying anything falls under that general rule, so your event sign-up sheet needs a tick box saying what they’ll receive.
Telling the right people when you’re closed
A short email the night before saves customers a wasted trip.
Holiday closures, shorter winter hours and a burst pipe all go to the whole list as short, plain messages, sent the day you know, with the dates in the subject line. Tag the people who order online when they sign up, so a change that only affects the counter reaches the people who use the counter.




























